Discussion about this post

User's avatar
钟建英's avatar

Hi I agree with a lot of what you say and thank you for your insights. However, as someone who has seen and experienced authoritarianism in the West and never in China, I take exception to your comment on needing to address authoritarianism in China. We regularly see police brutality in the West but never have I seen any equivalent brutality in China. If China censors social media, it is almost always to restrict prejudicial content, not reasoned discussion in policy matters. Whereas the West expressly censors debate about the Zionism and the British government even tells the media not to discuss certain topics at all. If China comes across as “authoritarian” it’s because capitalists do not set policy in China the way they freely do in the West. Also, the CIA and the British MI6 (and who knows what other Western and Israeli secret service do) think nothing of destabilising other societies, forcing non-Western governments to restrict protests instigated or encouraged by the CIA front known as the National Endowment for Democracy.

If you have not personally experienced authoritarianism in the West, I respectfully suggest that it’s because you are male and white. Think about this before you pontificate about authoritarianism in China.

To be clear, there are genuine areas where China could do better. For example, I wish Chinese censorship were subject to review by a “media tribunal”, so censorship comes across as less arbitrary. But please don’t propagate prejudicial attitudes about China!

Peter Holbrook's avatar

Thank you for this extremely informative, and persuasive, article. However, the following gave me pause: “Labour conditions can be brutal: precarity and intense competition in the labour market are visible realities. The welfare state remains thin. These are real structural problems…”. One wants to believe that China since the Deng / Opening Up period has remained in essence a socialist society, albeit one forced to make (NEP-style) large concessions to the prevailing international economic system—and so constitutes a genuine alternative to global capitalism. But that sentence of yours makes it difficult to hold to that belief! I would be very interested to know whether your research leads you to believe that contemporary China is indeed “socialist”—and any recommendations for further reading on this question would also be much appreciated.

23 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?